Continue to Site

Welcome to MCAD Central

Join our MCAD Central community forums, the largest resource for MCAD (Mechanical Computer-Aided Design) professionals, including files, forums, jobs, articles, calendar, and more.

Fun challenge: choose a computing server!

MichailS

New member
Hi there

The company I am working for has a dozen engineers doing analysies in Pro/M on rather old-school hardware. So I would like to pimp the concept of putting a stove in a corner that will only handle the solver bit, and preferrably also store FEA files, as the big corporate network is slow and the IT mongrels are complaining about storage.

I have been looking at offerings from SUN, HP, IBM and SGI, but I get lost in a forest of details. I would like a HPC computing server speced. Will you help me with this?

Assume that our budget for the hardware is around $50k or so.

Assume that we want the most bang for the buck, so old Netburst Xeons are probably out of the question. Opterons scale well with increasing CPUs, but Core Duo 2 Xeons seem to have the highest performance if you look at each one individually.

It is possible that Itanium2 or PA-RISC or other RISC CPU offerings could be worthwile, but I just don't know enough about them.

Assume that space is a small consideration, so I suppose blade servers are what we are looking for. If we can have it under a desk without getting our ears blown off, all is well. If it is a silent but full-size cupboard it is okay. If it needs a server room and a power plant of its own, it is not okay.

Assume that the RAM requirement is such as that today people are hitting the 3GB limit in Windows XP. I suppose most computations would fit 8 GB for the forseeable future.

Assume that the OS only matters in the sense that it must be 64-bit and run Pro/Mechanicas solver. The people here knows both UNIX, VMS and Windows.

Alternatively, I hear that one can use the ANSYS solver - is there any point in looking into that at all? They don't use the same method (P vs. M?) so why does this option exist at all?

I was looking at the SUN Fire X4600 and it looked quite nice at $36k, but it seems to only take two 2.5" SAS HDDs, which is inconvenient.
[url]http://store.sun.com/CMTemplate/CEServlet?process=SunStore&c mdStartWebConfig_CP&familyCode=SFX4600&baseSelected=2 [/url]

Edited by: MichailS
 
to avoid the 2 gig limit on 32 bit processors, i will advise to get a 64 bit machine. I have used HP C8000 and the new SUN Ultra 45 and they are super fast. Both these machine are UNIX and very powerfull. since your budget is 50K why dont you replace all the old machines new ones considering that you can get a medium Ultra 45 below $4600
http://store.sun.com/CMTemplate/CEServlet?process=SunStore&c mdViewProduct_CP&catid=144424

but again, whatever you do, make sure that you get a certified machine for Pro/ENGINEER.
http://www.ptc.com/partners/hardware/current/support.htm
 

Sponsor

Articles From 3DCAD World

Back
Top